weLEAD Online
Magazine
Copyright 2005 ã weLEAD, Inc.
Have you heard the story about a truck
that got stuck under a bridge? It is said that a box truck was attempting to
pass under a large bridge. As the truck driver approached the structure he felt
there was enough room to clear the bottom of the steel and concrete deck of the
bridge. But as he was passing under, he suddenly hear a loud screeching noise!
The screech turned in to a grind and the lurching truck came to a dead stop! It
was now locked under the bridge and could go neither forward
or backward. Putting the transmission in reverse, or one of the forward
gears was to no avail as the vehicle was now firmly lodged directly under the
bridge. Traffic came to a complete standstill and naturally the local
authorities were called out to examine the situation. How would they get the
truck out from under the bridge?
A tow truck was sent out to
try to pull the vehicle free. A county engineer arrived to examine this
difficult situation. There were deep discussions and many measurements were
made. Various calculations were performed to determine how much of the truck or
bridge would be destroyed if the vehicle was simply yanked or pulled out! If
too much of the bridge’s concrete was broken in the process, it might cause the
bridge to become unsafe. What if road equipment was brought in to cut a grove
into the road under the vehicle tires to lower it? What if heavy equipment was
brought in to lift the bridge just a few inches? Traffic continued to back up
and discussions raged on as frustrated workers and authorities pondered this difficult
problem. A crowd also gathered around the scene to watch all the exciting
activity and hubbub. Then something funny happened as a worker was walking by
part of the crowd and surveying the situation. A little boy who had previously
been riding his bicycle, and had stopped to glare, said to the man, “Why not
let the air out of the tires?”
“What?”, stated the worker in incredulous
shock! “What did you say?” The boy repeated, “Why not let the air out of the tires?” From this simple
observation and statement, an easy and effective solution was found to a
difficult problem that had confounded some very bright and energetic people!
What the little boy
demonstrated is what every effective leader needs to achieve personal success!
The boy had imagination. Within his
mind, he dug deep for a creative
solution and envisioned the vehicle becoming shorter because the tires would
lower the vehicle when air was removed from them. It was this imagination that
gave the boy the resourcefulness to solve a serious problem. Sadly, most
researchers tell us that we lose a
part of our creativity as we age. The innovative skills we learned at play as a child become lost as we enter
adulthood. However, many solutions to difficult problems are easily solved if
we learn to use our imagination and
mentally step outside our comfort
zone. This is a common problem in business today. Many managers believe that it
takes millions of dollars, and a severe culture shock to solve large problems
in their organizations. Like in the example above, when mountains are made out
of molehills, problem solving can become more difficult and costly than it
really needs to be.
As a leader, there will be
many times when emergencies, unexpected circumstances or complications arise to
block the path to our goals. There will also
be times when rational and analytical thinking isn’t good enough to make the
right or best decision! This is where we need to use our imagination as a resource to remove or to go around the obstacle.
Remember that during these kinds of demanding situations we should never panic.
We need a clear head and calm emotions to think logically and rapidly. In
addition, we also need to maintain
our composure in order for our imagination to be most effective and help us to
arrive at a wise decision. The time for passion
will arise later on when we act on the decision we have made, and make
it happen!
Earlier in our series on The
Twelve Principles of Personal Leadership we spoke about the essential
need for vision. It is a compelling vision that feeds our desire to accomplish
great things in life. Remember that our personal vision is the mental picture we
have that inspires us to establish, and seek our goals during good times and
bad! In this principle we will discuss the ability to once again tap
into our imagination to solve the
many problems that threaten to block us in achieving our goals. This can be
especially difficult for leaders who have a “black or white” view of the world.
If we define every person, event or activity as “good or bad” or “right or
wrong” we greatly limit our ability to solve problems creatively. The truth is
that some things are indeed “good or bad”, but most things are neutral unless
they are misused. To have a healthy creative imagination to solve problems
requires us to be open-minded and
look for the good in others and events, not the worse.
Obviously, to solve a problem
requires that we keep going forward
and not quit. Imagination is the resource that helps us to plow through an
obstacle! Some folks have a good vivid imagination naturally and have a reputation as an “idea
person”. But most of us need to do some research, seek advice and perform some
analysis to “prime the pump” of our imagination. It often requires us to think differently than we normally do. Asking
a series of “what if…” questions can often spark innovative solutions.
Organizations have found that the imagination generated during “brainstorming”
sessions can be very productive. However, the potential solutions we ponder
should always be legal, ethical and not intended to harm others. Sadly,
our prisons are populated with some
very creative and imaginative individuals. They allowed their imagination to be
used selfishly and to harm other people.
It is also important to realize that there is
usually more than one solution to
most problems. Even though it is desirable to find the best solution, it is not always practical. When this occurs, be
open-minded, and don’t delay making a critical decision because you are
searching for the perfect answer.
Some managers even use this as an excuse not to make the important
decisions that need to be made. When
you have faced a difficult challenge and used your imagination as a resource to
discover a solution, don’t stop there!
It is not enough to have imagination as a
resource if you are unwilling to make
the hard decisions. Possessing the right answer without the strength or will to
implement it will not solve difficult problems. Some folks are good at finding
solutions, but struggle to make
decisions. It
is easy to understand why many leaders want to avoid making decisions.
There are a number of valid reasons. First of all, it is often risky! Risk is defined as the possibility of suffering
harm, loss or danger. We tend to be comfortable in our patterns and
expectations. Often times making a decision means we must step out of our
“comfort zone” and into the unknown. Past experiences teach us that even a
slight shift in our course can have dramatic effects on an outcome. On a
personal level, we may have the right
answers but avoid making decisions
about our family, careers or finances because of an aversion to risk and fear
of failure. Secondly, leaders often make decisions while they are slightly ahead of the prevailing group or
culture. It is often a lonely, thankless experience with little visible
support. This situation is often compounded greatly
when the leader has not taken the time and energy to build a strong consensus
among others.
But
here is an important point about
decision-making and risk. We will frequently come to a crossroads in life or
business where an important decision must
be made. Then… we have a choice to make. Either we make the
decision, or “time and chance” will decide for us what we were unwilling to
decide for ourselves! Either way, a decision will be made. The question is,
will we take charge and assume greater control of the outcome, or will we allow
luck, chance or fate to determine the outcome for us? There is an old story
about two men drifting on a raft traveling down the Niagara River toward the
ominous Niagara Falls. They began to argue
about how far they were from the falls and when they should go ashore. The
argument continued and went on and on. While they haggled and
delayed making a decision, time made the decision for them, with
unfortunate results.
I am not suggesting
that you to lurch into ill-advised or poor decision-making. Leaders should seek
the facts, get advice, do the research and resourcefully find an answer. But
there does come a time when a decision…the decision must be made! It has
been said that former American President and World War II General Dwight D.
Eisenhower once commented, “A wrong decision is better than indecision”. Think
about why a military General would have made this comment. A wrong decision is
at least a choice, and if that choice is wrong there if often enough
time to retrench, regroup and alter the course. Creativity is flexible and can
be modified early in the decision process. However, indecision only erodes precious time and often removes the option
of an alternative choice from the
decision maker. Sometimes the real
risk is not taking one. As author and educator Gary Dessler
states, “Very few decisions are forever; there is more “give” in most decisions
than we realize. While many major strategic decisions are hard to reverse, most
poor decisions won’t mean the end of the world for you, so don’t become frozen
in the finality of your decision”.
At
the heart and core of leadership is also the willingness to take personal responsibility for a difficult decision.
On June 6, 1944, during World War II, General Eisenhower agonized over a
difficult decision to allow Allied forces to land on the beaches of Normandy,
France. The weather had been poor and threatened to derail the Allied assault.
A window of opportunity was closing and it was time for decisive action.
Eisenhower finally gave approval for the landing. However, he also took the
time to write an “official statement” to the media in case the landing failed
and the Allies were unable to secure a beachhead. In his handwritten
announcement, Eisenhower accepted full responsibility for the failure.
Thankfully, it was never needed!
Many
experts in management believe that not all decisions are the same. They
differentiate between what they call programmed and nonprogrammed
decisions. Programmed decisions are defined as ones that are repetitive and can
typically be resolved through rational analysis and mechanical procedures. It
is believed that the overwhelming majority of decisions we make are programmed
decisions. Standard rules of deduction can be applied to these decision types.
These kinds of decisions do not require a great degree of imagination.
On
the other hand, nonprogrammed decisions are
defined as unique in nature. These include crisis
situations or when we have arrived at a personal crossroad in our life. Nonprogrammed
decisions rely heavily on our
judgment and values rather than clear-cut analysis. They are typically more
urgent and require greater focus. We all must eventually face them… the tough
agonizing decisions that often need to be based on incomplete information and
unknown criteria! Sometimes there is no clear
choice of what or who is absolutely right or wrong. There may be little
“black and white”, but rather shades of gray. Using our positive ethics and
deep-seated values as a guide, we will need to muster all the creativity and
intuition we can find deep within ourselves for a solution. Because these nonprogrammed decisions are usually critical, the
risk and consequences can be great, but don’t let that stop you from taking
action when required!
Here
are a few tips to improve your
decision-making ability. Recognize the facts as they really are and not
how you want to see them. It is easy to ignore or distort the truth
because we already desire to support
a particular answer. For example, those who study theology often fall prey to a
problem called proof-texting. This is where the theologian first comes
to a personal conclusion, and then looks for scriptures to support a
preconceived belief. Many scientists are
also guilty of the same problem.
Maintain your objectivity so your decision is based on an intelligent analysis
of the actual facts and not a preconceived decision. Along with analysis, don’t
be afraid to use your heart as long as it is not blinded by raw emotion! A
balanced decision is one that is made from both the head and the heart. This is
where you make a decision based on accumulated experience, knowledge and intuition.
Remember, having firm personal values and strong ethics is the foundation of good intuition.
Psychiatrist Sigmund Freud stated,
“When making a decision
of minor importance I have always found it advantageous to consider all the
pros and cons. In vital matters, however, such as the choice of a mate or a
profession, the decision should come from the unconscious, from somewhere
within ourselves. In the important decisions of our personal life, we should be
governed, I think, by the deep inner needs of our nature.”
Obviously
if the deep inner needs of our nature are centered on integrity and
genuine concern for others, our intuition will serve us well. Another
decision-making tip is to be careful not to use shortcuts to save time. A common shortcut is called heuristics.
This is used to speed up decision-making by applying “rules of thumb” to
quickly reach a conclusion. For example, a senior manager may say, “I only want
individuals with advanced degrees to apply for this position”. Yes, this
may speed up the selection process, but may also mean the best qualified
or most talented individual is not even considered for the position. The final
tip I offer is to avoid anchoring. The trait of anchoring is where we
give too much credence to the first communication or set of facts that
we hear. This first bit of information then becomes the benchmark by which the
decision will be made and later information that is contrary to it is
dismissed or minimized.
So the next time you are
confronted with the need to make a decision, remember the little boy gazing at
the truck stuck under a bridge. The best answer will require using your imagination as a resource. Challenge
yourself to think differently and from a fresh perspective. When you have made
a decision and an answer is at hand, don’t stop there! A leader’s calling
is to make the hard decisions when they are needed. No one said the job is
easy! Yes, there is a risk to decision-making, but there is often a greater
risk when we do nothing and allow fate to decide for us. So be sure you gather
the facts, get sound advice, and do the necessary research. Then make the
decision. If you get stuck… maybe you need to just step back and look at things
differently. Perhaps you will even need to let some of the air out!
Comments
to: editor@leadingtoday.org
To see
all Greg’s articles click
here.
About the author:
Greg has an extensive thirty-five years experience in public
speaking and has spoken to hundreds of audiences worldwide. Greg has a Master
of Arts degree in Leadership from
Bellevue University, where he also has served as an adjunct professor teaching
courses in business management and leadership since 2002. His first book, 52 Leadership Tips
(That Will Change How You Lead Others) was published
in 2006 by WingSpan Press. His second book, Making
Life's Puzzle Pieces Fit was published in March 2009. Both are available at
amazon.com. Greg is also the president of Leadership
Excellence, Ltd and a Managing Partner of the Leadership Management
Institute. Leadership
Excellence, Ltd. effectively builds
individuals and organizations to reach their highest potential through enhanced
productivity and personal development using a number of proven programs. He is also the president and founder
of weLEAD Incorporated.